mother nature

Paws and Effect: A Menagerie of Creatures Creating Subway Delays

Lucy Blair waits with her French Bulldog, Ace, at the Nevins Street station in Brooklyn, Jan. 2, 2019.
Lucy Blair waits with her French Bulldog, Ace, at the Nevins Street station in Brooklyn, Jan. 2, 2019. Photo: Ben Fractenberg/THE CITY

Sign up for “THE CITY Scoop,” our daily newsletter where we send you stories like this first thing in the morning.

It’s not just raccoons that have slowed the subway.

Dogs, geese, possums and turkeys are among the animals that delayed close to 900 trains since 2016 — and 238 last year, according to MTA figures and internal reports obtained by THE CITY.

“It’s one thing to have rats on the tracks, but when it’s other animals that get on the tracks, that’s scary,” said Eric Courtney, 50, who was waiting for a train at the Nevins St. station in Downtown Brooklyn, which in recent months had become home to a pesky raccoon dubbed Chepe.

Police officers safely corralled a raccoon that was loose at the Nevins Street station.
Police officers safely corralled a raccoon that was loose at the Nevins Street station. Photo: Seth Gross

While animal interference accounts for a sliver of the nearly 30,000 weekday delays in the subway each month, they did increase slightly in 2019, MTA figures show. Through mid-December, there were 33 incidents that were caused by animals — a third of which were pinned on raccoons. That was up from 29 the previous year and nearly triple the figure from 2017.

One incident can account for multiple train delays. Raccoons delayed 87 trains, coming in second only to dogs who found their way onto subway tracks. Canines were tied to 107 separate train delays last year.

Your Garbage Attracts Critters

A spokesperson for the state Department of Environmental Conservation noted that raccoons, possums and skunks are the forms of wildlife most commonly spotted on outdoor stretches of the subway, where some are drawn to discarded food or prey on subway rats.

“The Brighton Beach Line on the Q and B has had raccoons and possums getting run over by trains for years,” train operator Canella Gomez told THE CITY. “It’s just now, for some strange reason, raccoons are showing up on platforms. Truthfully, it’s probably from all the food customers throw on the floors.”

Eric Loegel, vice president of rapid transit operations for TWU Local 100, said that animal strikes can set off trains’ emergency brakes.

“Any emergency brake activation where the cause is unknown requires an investigation — it’s a solid 20- or 30-minute delay, sometimes more,” he noted.

Goose on the Loose

Feathered members of the animal kingdom got in the way of commuters, too.

A turkey briefly caused delays to N train service during the June 13 morning rush, an incident report shows, after getting loose on the open-cut tracks near the 8 Avenue station in Sunset Park.

And a goose on the tracks near the Parkside Avenue stop in Flatbush caused 16 service changes on the Q and B lines last February until police could remove it from tracks.

Goats, at least, managed to stay off the tracks last year after a high-profile jaunt onto Brooklyn N train tracks in 2018.

An MTA spokesperson said subway supervisors and crews handle animal incidents on a case-by-case basis when deciding whether to slow or halt subway service because of a furry intruder on the tracks.

Last year’s animal diversions began on Jan. 2, when a pooch that had been missing for days darted from the Essex Street station on the Lower East Side onto the Williamsburg Bridge and headed toward Brooklyn. The dog’s dash caused the power to be cut on the tracks, and reports show it led to 39 service changes on the J and M lines over nearly two hours of delays for 14 trains.

‘Use a Pouch’

The dog, named Jake, was reunited with his owners after being plucked from the tracks by police. But another pooch that freed itself from its harness met a tragic end in May after escaping onto the tracks and disappearing into a tunnel at 34th Street-Herald Square.

“God forbid your dog gets loose on the tracks,” said Lucy Blair, 29, a Brooklyn straphanger who was carrying her French Bulldog puppy, Ace, in a pouch on her chest. “That’s why I always use a pouch, because you can’t expect a dog to be as responsible as you are.”

Two goats wandered onto the N line tracks in Brooklyn in August, 2018.
Two goats wandered onto the N line tracks in Brooklyn in August, 2018. Photo: Marc A. Hermann/MTA New York City Transit

MTA figures show dogs on the tracks have been responsible for 443 separate train delays since 2016, including the 107 last year. Cats, meanwhile, have had been less troublesome, delaying 172 trains since 2016, with only two in 2019.

A pair of kittens famously disrupted Q and B service for nearly two hours in August 2013 when they wandered onto the tracks near the Church Avenue stop in Flatbush. Train service was suspended twice before the kittens were rescued.

Their trek on the tracks led former MTA Chairman Joe Lhota, who was then running for mayor, to say he would have kept the trains running, resulting in a screaming “Die Kitties Die!” front page in the Daily News.

Want to republish this story? See our republication guidelines.

SUPPORT THE CITY

You just finished reading another story from THE CITY.

We need your help to make THE CITY all it can be.

Please consider joining us as a member today.

DONATE TODAY!